Home Platforms With Atlas Relaunch, Facebook Advances New Cross-Device ID Based On Logged In Users

With Atlas Relaunch, Facebook Advances New Cross-Device ID Based On Logged In Users


atlas-facebookFacebook has done something big with the relaunch of its Atlas ad server, acquired from Microsoft 16 months ago, but that something has little to do with serving ads. Rather it’s about replacing the beleaguered cookie with a new, more reliable ad-tracking mechanism for the mobile age.

The new Atlas – expected to be unveiled Monday – leverages the relationships Facebook has with users who are logged in across devices to support a new persistent tracking mechanism. This ID, which strips out all but the most basic information about a Facebook user, is the first salvo in what many expect to be a series of moves by large Internet companies such as Google, Yahoo, Amazon and Twitter to use the login as the foundation of ad personalization and measurement.

“What we’re bringing to the table is mobile,” said David Jakubowski, who joined the company recently to head up Atlas and the Facebook Audience Network, the company’s nascent ad network. “When you run an ad on Facebook, they know because you’re logged in. We’ve partnered with all the major apps and ad networks and exchanges very specifically around the mobile world to enable Atlas to receive the ad events. When the ad runs from those places, we can use that to tie back all of the channels.”

With the new cross-device measurement solution, Atlas will also begin to support other features, such as retargeting and pooling data from different sources, that have traditionally been the domain of specialized vendors such as data-management platforms and demand-side platforms.

But the new Atlas has its limits, chief among them that marketers are constrained in their ability to intermingle Facebook’s cross-device data with other forms of first- and third-party data they house in outside platforms such as Acxiom. In short: Facebook’s new tracking standard may be ready-made for the multidevice era, but you can’t “take it with you.”

New Measurement Standard For A Multidevice Future

On Monday, Facebook will reveal a new version of Atlas with a completely new code base and user interface. (Read the blog post.)

Facebook says Atlas can serve display, video and mobile ads nearly anywhere that its chief competitor, Google’s DoubleClick For Advertisers (DFA), has been certified. What’s more, it has for the moment a major leg up on DFA in that it can accurately identify and serve ads to users across their devices. This cross-device capability works not only on Facebook’s owned and operated properties – namely Facebook.com, the Facebook mobile app and Instagram – but on thousands of other websites and apps as well.

How it does this is a little tricky to understand. Because not all apps and websites use Facebook’s social login, Atlas uses cookies in combination with the Facebook ID to identify users on websites in a desktop environment. And on mobile, it uses a combination of its Facebook ID, its Facebook SDK for apps and mobile device identifiers such as Apple’s Identifier for Advertising (IDFA) and Android’s Advertising ID.

Facebook can achieve a “match” using device identifiers for any user that stays logged in on a phone or tablet, even when those users are accessing apps that don’t use Facebook login.

Atlas has also done integrations with search advertising platforms such as Marin, so a marketer can import impression data from their search campaigns and track those alongside display and video ads.


AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

Omnicom Connection

Atlas has about 20 large marketers using its ad server today, but hopes to attract many times that number. To jump-start that growth, it has signed Omnicom Group as a launch partner. Atlas will be offered through Omnicom’s data and analytics division, Annalect, which is shared across the holding company’s operating agencies.

Speaking with AdExchanger, Omnicom Digital CEO Jonathan Nelson said the choice about whether to use Atlas will be up to the advertiser.

“Annalect sits under everything when it comes to data and ad serving,” Nelson said. “We make recommendations, but the decision about what ad server to use will be client by client.”

The message to advertisers is essentially this: You can continue to serve campaigns with DFA, but if you serve it with Atlas you’re going to get a richer data set. Nelson added Atlas is not an all-or-nothing proposition for clients: “We’re going to run hybrids. Part runs over here, part runs over there.”

Facebook As Data Platform

The new Atlas, and its cross-device ID, holds promise as a tracking solution that could surpass the so-called “probabilistic” user identification methods that have been developed in recent years by vendors such as Drawbridge, Tapad and AdTruth/41st Parameter (acquired by Experian). Those probabilistic methods rely on unique device attributes to achieve desktop-to-mobile user match rates in the range of 60 to 80%, according to some sources.

What’s more, Facebook may be positioning Atlas as a standalone data-management platform. Jakubowski said Atlas will be able to ingest a wide range of data, including first-party data, and use it to bid on, serve and track ad placements.

“You can now bring first-party data, offline data, CRM data. You can onboard it and use it to more accurately target your media” within the Atlas environment, he said.


There are limits to Facebook’s approach to cross-device ad serving. Most importantly, Atlas will not allow its cross-device data to leave Facebook’s walls, and that is likely to restrict its usefulness as an ad-tracking standard.

While advertisers will be able to import their own data into Atlas to serve and track campaigns in the ad server environment, and even target users through real-time bidding, they cannot then take the cross-device user profiles from their those campaigns and merge them with their own data in outside platforms.

The simple reason, Facebook said, is user privacy. Letting advertisers take Atlas’s cross-device tracking information out of the Facebook system, where it could potentially be matched to other audience pools, is a non-starter. “We are not giving the translation layer” to outside players, Jakubowski said. “You would be able to access all of the people-level reporting inside of the Atlas walls and inside of the Atlas reporting interface.”

But for advertisers that want to centrally manage their audience and customer data across all touch points, this may be a sticking point, according to Matt Spiegel, SVP and GM of marketing and technology solutions at MediaLink, a consulting firm that advises marketers and other companies on digital strategy.

“To me it’s a company like Acxiom that can design the focus of a marketer ID system or a customer identification client,” Spiegel said. “Fundamentally that’s what marketers need. It needs to take in that Facebook ID, it needs to take in whatever Google ID they’re going to share. It needs to take in third-party cookies. It needs to take in first-party cookies. It needs to take in their LiveRamp onboarding data.”

Over time Facebook believes it can support workarounds for the ID portability problem. For instance, the company may explore ways to allow marketers and outside data platforms to build on top of Atlas, similar to how the company’s Preferred Marketing Developers have leveraged Facebook’s Ads API, suggested one person with knowledge of Facebook’s plans. But how such an API model would play out is unclear.

Another issue is that Atlas doesn’t have 100% match rates for inventory outside of its walled garden.

Facebook has been working hard to put partnerships in place that secure as much reach as it can for its cross-device ID. Facebook said these partnerships cover 50% of all time spent on mobile. Adding in Facebook’s owned and operated properties, namely Facebook and Instagram, the number grows further, to about three and a half of every five minutes users spend on mobile. That’s a lot of authenticated mobile users, but it’s not all.

And that limits the Facebook ID’s promise as a true replacement for the third-party cookie.

Big Picture: Facebook’s Ad Tech Ambitions

The relaunch of Atlas, coupled with the recent acquisition of video sell-side platform LiveRail, underscores Facebook’s large ambitions in the digital advertising arena that extend far beyond its owned and operated properties.

“We’re out talking to advertisers, we’re testing it, and very quickly they see the insight,” Jakubowski said. “The shift to people-based measurement is massive for them. The next question they’re asking is can you now help me take action on this.”

The obvious answer is launching a DSP, DMP and exchange platform. But Facebook doesn’t think in terms of easy buckets.

Jakubowski continued, “Ad tech for Facebook is a little bit of white space. … We need to get more formalized about how we think about ad tech. How do we partner with the ecosystem? How do we create a space where lots of the right things can happen?”

Facebook sees the ad server, and its role in measuring audiences and campaigns, as a good place to initiate its new vision for people-based marketing. DMP and DSP capabilities – whether build, buy or partner – can come later.

“Facebook acts as almost a panel for the ad server,” Jakubowski said. “You can start to attack the problems of cross-device and a lot of the things cookies have limitations for, and you can drive measurement more toward real people-based initiatives. You’re attacking the pain points, and creating a tool set and a platform. That’s what we think about first.”

Must Read

shopping cart

Moloco Invests In Its Competitor Topsort As The Retail Media Stakes Go Up

Topsort can lean into Moloco’s algorithmic personalization, while Moloco benefits from Topsort’s footprint with local retailers in the US and in Latin America.

CDP BlueConic Acquires First-Party Data Collection Startup Jebbit

On Wednesday, customer data platform BlueConic bought Jebbit, which creates quizzes, surveys and other interactive online plugs for collecting data from customers.

Comic: The Showdown (Google vs. DOJ)

The DOJ’s Witness List For The Google Antitrust Trial Is A Who’s Who Of Advertising

The DOJ published the witness list for its upcoming antitrust trial against Google, and it reads like the online advertising industry’s answer to the Social Register.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

Why Vodafone Is Giving Out Grades For Its Creative

One way to get a handle on your brand creative is to, well, grade your homework, according to Anne Stilling, Vodafone’s global director of brands and media.

Inside The Fall Of Oracle’s Advertising Business

By now, the industry is well aware that Oracle, once the most prominent advertising data seller in market, will shut down its advertising division. What’s behind the ignominious end of Oracle Advertising?

Forget about asking for permission to collect cookies. Google will have to ask for permission to not collect them.

Criteo: The Privacy Sandbox Is NOT Ready Yet, But Could Be If Google Makes Certain Changes Soon

If Google were to shut off third-party cookies today and implement the current version of the Privacy Sandbox, publishers would see their ad revenue on Chrome tank by around 60% on average.