Let’s Take the Google Ad Exchange Conversation to the Sell Side for a Minute

“The Sell-Sider” is a new column written by the sell-side of the digital media community.

Michael Barrett is CEO of AdMeld, a publisher yield optimization company.

Michael Barrett of AdMeld There’s been a lot of interesting talk over the past few weeks about the potential impact of Google Ad Exchange. While there seems to be consensus that the platform will catalyze the adoption of real time bidding and the exchange model in general, most of the analysis (as noted by FarneyMedia) has been from and about the buy side. But from AdMeld’s perspective, I’m most interested in the role AdEx may play in the lives of our clients—the web’s premium publishers.

Like most things Google, AdEx brings to bear some smart technical features. For instance, by connecting the exchange with DFP, Google’s built a nice onramp into the platform for large publishers. That kind of convenience is important, but it’s just one part of the equation. For AdEx or any exchange to succeed, it will have to demonstrate superior monetization capabilities on the sell side. That means delivering the highest possible yield for every impression at 100% fill, and doing it better than the top players in the space. As Mike Cassidy of Undertone said recently, “publishers are better off selling through multiple channels than one transparent channel at lower rates.”

Beyond monetization, premium publishers are looking for more than just technology to help them navigate the ad space. In an increasingly complex landscape, publishers want partners and advocates with expertise ranging from emerging sources of demand to data strategies to minimizing issues like cannibalization. Speaking of cannibalization, I had a recent conversation with a client in which he acknowledged the need for more efficiency in the industry but asked: “If I lean into exchanges whole-heartedly, will it turn my $0.50 remnant CPM into $3 (a good thing) or my $30 premium CPM into $3? (a not so good thing.)” We’ve heard it before, but this is a persistent and legitimate concern for top-tier publishers. Without their confident participation, the exchange model simply won’t deliver. I don’t think Google wants to help publishers strategize around these types of issues, and if they did, the inherent conflicts of also running an ad network would make it a difficult sell, even if those conflicts never actually came into play.

While some have speculated that Mountain View will come to dominate the exchange space, I think it’s an unlikely scenario. Google will find a way to play a meaningful role in display advertising, but as Darren Herman said in a recent post on this site, the industry has yet to see one platform in any segment (including PPC, Google’s core business) that meets everyone’s needs. Whatever happens with Google specifically, AdEx and similar platforms are spurring a new wave of innovation and competition that will make it a lot easier to transact display advertising inventory—and that’s a good thing for everyone. Forgive the industry-thought-piece cliché, but it really is an exciting time to be in this space.

Follow AdMeld (@admeld) and AdExchanger.com (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

Comic: What Else? (Google, Jedi Blue, Project Bernanke)

Google antitrust

Project Cheat Sheet: A Rundown On All Of Google’s Secret Internal Projects, As Revealed By The DOJ

What do Hercule Poirot, Ben Bernanke, Star Wars and C.S. Lewis have in common? If you’re an ad tech nerd, you’ll know the answer immediately.

Commerce Media

The Wonderful Brand Discusses Testing OOH And Online Snack Competition

Wonderful hadn’t done an out-of-home (OOH) marketing push in more than 15 years. That is, until a week ago, when it began a campaign across six major markets to promote its new no-shell pistachio packs.

Google filed a motion to exclude the testimony of any government witnesses who aren’t economists or antitrust experts during the upcoming ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.

Google antitrust trial

Google Is Fighting To Keep Ad Tech Execs Off the Stand In Its Upcoming Antitrust Trial

Google doesn’t want AppNexus founder Brian O’Kelley – you know, the godfather of programmatic – to testify during its ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.

ad fraud

How HUMAN Uncovered A Scam Serving 2.5 Billion Ads Per Day To Piracy Sites

Publishers trafficking in pirated movies, TV shows and games sold programmatic ads alongside this stolen content, while using domain cloaking to obscure the “cashout sites” where the ads actually ran.

In 2019, Google moved to a first-price auction and also ceded its last look advantage in AdX, in part because it had to. Most exchanges had already moved to first price.

Google antitrust trial

Thanks To The DOJ, We Now Know What Google Really Thought About Header Bidding

Starting last week and into this week, hundreds of court-filed documents have been unsealed in the lead-up to the Google ad tech antitrust trial – and it’s a bonanza.

CTV Roundup

Will Alternative TV Currencies Ever Be More Than A Nielsen Add-On?

Ever since Nielsen was dinged for undercounting TV viewers during the pandemic, its competitors have been fighting to convince buyers and sellers alike to adopt them as alternatives. And yet, some industry insiders argue that alt currencies weren’t ever meant to supplant Nielsen.

Must Read

Popular