Home The Big Story The Looming Question Of Cookie Consent

The Looming Question Of Cookie Consent

SHARE:

Here’s the old news: Chrome cookies are (eventually) going away.

Here’s the new news: Only some cookies are going away.

Google Chrome is proposing an “approach that elevates user choice,” which will undoubtedly mean more opt-outs. But will the opt-out rate be half? Two-thirds? 10%? 90%?

For the past week or so, we’ve been so caught up in Google’s revision of its all-or-nothing approach, we’ve forgotten that cookies are still going to be scarcer and scarcer.

If half of cookies go away, it would mean a cookie opt-in that roughly matches Apple’s AppTrackingTransparency. And if it’s more? Less? The percentage of cookie opt outs will depend on the type of user choice Google chooses.

Google hasn’t shared much about how it plans to gain users’ consent, but how it designs its prompt will attract the attention of regulators and draw comparisons – like the one I make on this week’s podcast – to Apple’s AppTrackingTransparency.

What might impact Google’s approach to user choice? We discuss everything from dark patterns to the regulators who are paying attention to how it designs its prompt.

Then, when Chrome deprecated cookies for 1% of its traffic in January, it revealed that some cookie-seeming IDs were still attached to this traffic, a practice called ID bridging. Our senior editor, James Hercher, covered the ensuing debate around ID bridging: Is it ethical? When is it okay? Can DSPs make informed choices, too, about whether to opt in to ID bridging?

Since much of web traffic today does not have cookies, and since the amount of cookies will decrease once Google implements its consent choices, ID bridging remains relevant. It also peels back ad tech’s varnish and exposes the Jerry-rigged parts below the hood.

 

Must Read

Albert Thompson, Managing Director, Digital at Walton Isaacson

To Cure What Ails Digital Advertising, Marketers And Publishers Must Get Back To Basics

Albert Thompson, a buy-side veteran with 20+ years of experience, weighs in on attention metrics, the value of MFA sites, brand safety backlash and how publishers can improve their inventory.

A comic depiction of Google's ad machine sucking money out of a publisher.

DOJ vs. Google, Day Five Rewind: Prebid Reality Check, Unfair Rev Share And Jedi Blue (Sorta)

Someone will eventually need to make a Netflix-style documentary about the Google ad tech antitrust trial happening in Virginia. (And can we call it “You’ve Been Ad Served?”)

Comic: Alphabet Soup

Buried DOJ Evidence Reveals How Google Dealt With The Trade Desk

In the process of the investigation into Google, the Department of Justice unearthed a vast trove of separate evidence. Some of these findings paint a whole new picture of how Google interacts and competes with its main DSP rival, The Trade Desk.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Comic: The Unified Auction

DOJ vs. Google, Day Four: Behind The Scenes On The Fraught Rollout Of Unified Pricing Rules

On Thursday, the US district court in Alexandria, Virginia boarded a time machine back to April 18, 2019 – the day of a tense meeting between Google and publishers.

Google Ads Will Now Use A Trusted Execution Environment By Default

Confidential matching – which uses a TEE built on Google Cloud infrastructure – will now be the default setting for all uses of advertiser first-party data in Customer Match.

In 2019, Google moved to a first-price auction and also ceded its last look advantage in AdX, in part because it had to. Most exchanges had already moved to first price.

Unraveling The Mystery Of PubMatic’s $5 Million Loss From A “First-Price Auction Switch”

PubMatic’s $5 million loss from DV360’s bidding algorithm fix earlier this year suggests second-price auctions aren’t completely a thing of the past.