Home Agencies Redefining Transparency

Redefining Transparency

SHARE:

Joanna L. O’Connell is Manager of Strategic Development, ATOM Systems, Razorfish.

the executionerThe word “transparency” seems to be everyone’s favorite word these days. Clients want it, publishers fear it, and networks – increasingly – boast that they offer it. I’d like to propose that we’re thinking about this word in the wrong way and suggest that we as an industry consider changing our definition.

First, some background. In my previous life as a media supervisor, I spent most of my days working on campaigns featuring 5 to 15 3rd party ad networks at any given time. While our network-heavy plans generally performed well from a direct response standpoint, they didn’t tell us much about what was working and why. From an optimization standpoint, I was very limited, making poorly-informed, surface-level optimization decisions which never seemed to lead to the same result (“let’s cut the 728×90’s… no wait, let’s put those back in…no wait!”). While maybe we knew what sites we “might” be running on thanks to the fully transparent site list we sometimes received, we never knew what was actually happening and why so we could learn and repeat it.

It was with much enthusiasm, then, that I approached the exchange landscape as a buyer. While the exchanges didn’t seem to offer much in the way of site-level transparency, they did offer the promise of direct control, insight and repeatability–all the elements which I’d been missing in my experience with networks. For the first time, I had access to a multitude of optimization levers never before at my disposal: things like geo, time of day, day of week, not to mention ad size and creative concept. I was able to “see under the hood” of my exchange campaigns and could finally start to answer the big question: what kinds of impressions convert and at what price should I buy them? I could make repeatable buying decisions, not to mention share new insights, time after time. This was a wholly different kind of transparency.

Certainly, I understand the desire to answer the question, “Yes, but where are my ads running?” And, I absolutely believe that serving as good stewards of clients’ brands by keeping their advertising out of questionable or otherwise unsavory content is paramount. But being able to answer all kinds of other important questions that tap into the heart of what’s driving campaign success or failure is a great leap forward, no matter how you cut it.

That said, buyers will continue to push for site level transparency and, as was the case in the network space, the exchanges will likely evolve to be more “transparent” in the traditional sense. But I would hate for buyers – and their clients – to miss out on a totally new kind of transparency that is available right now on the exchanges.

Follow Razorfish (@Razorfish) and AdExchanger.com (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

Intent IQ Has Patents For Ad Tech’s Most Basic Functions – And It’s Not Afraid To Use Them

An unusual dilemma has programmatic vendors and ad tech platforms worried about a flurry of potential patent infringement suits.

TikTok Video For Open Web Publishers? Outbrain Built It.

Outbrain is trying to shed its chumbox rep by bringing social media-style vertical video to mobile publishers on the open web.

Billups Launches Attention Measurement For Out-Of-Home

Billups, a managed services agency that specializes in OOH, is making its attention measurement solution and a related analytics dashboard available for general use.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
US District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, Alexandria

The Google Ad Tech Antitrust Case Is Over – And Here’s What’s Happening Next

Just three weeks after it began, the Google ad tech antitrust trial in Virginia is over. The court will now take a nearly two-month break before reconvening for closing arguments right before Thanksgiving.

Jounce Media's Chris Kane at Programmatic IO NY on Sept. 25, 2024.

The Bidstream Is A Duplicative, Chaotic Mess – But It Doesn’t Have To Be That Way

Publishers are initiating more and more auctions – but doesn’t mean DSPs are listening to more bids, according to Chris Kane.

Readers Are Flocking To Political News, Says WaPo – And Advertisers Are Missing Out

During certain periods this year, advertisers blocked more than 40% of The Washington Post’s inventory over brand safety concerns.