Home Online Advertising Ad Trade Groups Sound The Alarm As Apple Closes The First-Party Cookie Jar

Ad Trade Groups Sound The Alarm As Apple Closes The First-Party Cookie Jar

SHARE:

Six ad industry trade groups have called for Apple to rethink an upcoming change to Safari that will unilaterally block some first-party cookies.

Apple’s Safari browser started blocking third-party cookies by default earlier this summer with the release of its Intelligent Tracking Prevention, a machine learning-based feature that discourages cross-site user tracking.

But an extension of that tracking policy going live next week creates “a set of haphazard rules over the use of first-party cookies,” according to Thursday’s letter signed by the American Association of Advertising Agencies, Interactive Advertising Bureau, Association of National Advertisers (ANA), Data & Marketing Association, American Advertising Federation and Network Advertising Initiative.

One major concern is that Safari’s tracking prevention isn’t based on a hard-and-fast policy. Apple makes decisions on the fly as it learns what certain tags do and what users prefer.

“The infrastructure of the modern internet depends on consistent and generally applicable standards for cookies,” according to the six trade groups.

Apple’s guidance on Intelligent Tracking Prevention doesn’t discount the possibility of tracking across the web, but “(classifies) which top privately controlled domains have the ability to track the user cross-site.”

For example, both Facebook and Criteo connect identities across the web via cookies placed on sites in each company’s publisher network. But Apple’s machine-learning software could distinguish between those programs because Facebook claims a relationship with its users whereas Criteo is directly connected only to the publisher.

Criteo may use a first-party cookie, but Apple won’t treat it like a first-party stakeholder.

“Apple has a long history of preventing tracking of users by companies who have zero relationship with the users,” said Jason Kint, CEO of the news media trade group Digital Content Next.

Dan Jaffe, an executive at the ANA, said the Safari policy takes user choice out of the equation since Apple will make judgment calls on which cookies can stay without individual input.

“We think the consumer should be key in this process,” he told AdExchanger. “This isn’t about a publisher being clear about their tags and a person saying ‘no.’”

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

Kint said Intelligent Tracking Prevention may not be a perfect solution, but that it will more closely align with consumer expectations by blocking intermediaries without user relationships “from employing cross-site tracking workarounds.”

Although, what is a barrier if not a chance for a new workaround?

The Apple policy update “will create a challenge to the environment in general,” Criteo CEO Eric Eichmann told investors in a brief aside while announcing an unrelated retail data product Thursday.

Eichmann said Criteo is working on solutions that could mitigate the effects of Intelligent Tracking Prevention, and he compared the efforts to previous issues like ad blocking and cross-channel identity that shake up the industry before stabilizing into a status quo.

Advertising attribution and analytics will also be affected, since third-party measurement vendors sometimes piggyback on first-party cookies as well.

“Blocking cookies in this manner will drive a wedge between brands and their customers,” wrote the co-signing trade groups. “And it will make advertising more generic and less timely and useful.”

Must Read

Can Publishers Trust The Trade Desk’s New Wrapper?

TTD says OpenAds is not just a reaction to Prebid’s TID change, but a new model for fairer, more transparent ad auctions. So what does the DSP need to do to get publishers to adopt its new auction wrapper?

Scott Spencer’s New Startup Wants To Help Users Monetize Their Online Advertising Data

What happens when an ad tech developer partners with a cybersecurity expert to start a new company? You end up with a consumer product that is both a privacy software service and a programmatic advertising ID.

Former FTC commissioner Alvaro Bedoya speaks to AdExchanger Managing Editor Allison Schiff at Programmatic IO NY 2025.

Advertisers Probably Shouldn’t Target Teens At All, Cautions Former FTC Commissioner

Alvaro Bedoya shared his qualms with digital advertising’s more controversial targeting tactics and how kids use gen AI and social media.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

Wall Street Turned Against Ad Tech – But May Learn To Love It Again

What can pureplay ad tech companies do to clean up their rep on the Street?

AppsFlyer and Roku’s New SRN Integration Will Shed Light On CTV Campaign Impact

Roku and AppsFlyer announced the launch of a new self-reporting network (SRN) integration between both companies, which will allow mobile app advertisers to more effectively measure their streaming video campaigns

Comic: Gamechanger (Google lost the DOJ's search antitrust case)

DOJ v. Google: How Judge Brinkema Seems To Be Thinking After Week One

Where the DOJ v. Google ad tech antitrust trial stands after one week’s worth of remedies arguments.