Home Mobile Are Programmatically Purchased Native Ads Native Enough?

Are Programmatically Purchased Native Ads Native Enough?

SHARE:

Native-adsIt seems everyone and their mothers are pushing native ad units and tools to support them. Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo and most recently AOL all have native, in-feed ad units.

As these formats catch on, ad tech companies like Sharethrough, Nativo and DistroScale have developed tools designed to automate ad distribution across different publishers’ sites while matching the format of each site. But while automatically generated native ads might mimic the look and feel of the content surrounding them, it’s often unclear how well these units actually blend with their publisher hosts.

“Does (the ad) just match the shape of a news tile? Or is it integrated into the publisher or app’s content?” said Forrester Research analyst Jennifer Wise.

To be truly native, an in-feed ad must match the site’s layout as well as its content, said Sacha Xavier, media and innovation partner at Neo@Ogilvy. For example, placing an in-feed mobile gaming install ad on a news site would be just as disruptive as a banner ad, Xavier pointed out. “Native ads should be curated the same way you would curate content on a page,” she said.

Jenn Cox, mobility lead at Starcom USA, agreed.

“The ads that perform best provide the type of utility that a user would normally seek out,” Cox said. “Are you adding something that’s relevant to that platform and tailored to the users’ behavior?”

As with traditional display ads, relevance is crucial. To various degrees, vendors like Facebook, Nativo, Sharethrough and DistroScale allow clients to target their in-feed ads against criteria like geography, audience, devices and page location. They also provide analytic capabilities to further optimize the ads.

However, contextually and programmatically matched in-feed ads are not native ads, argued JiYoung Kim, SVP of creative solutions and strategy at Ansible Mobile.

“I would just call that contextual marketing,” she said. Native advertising involves providing an ad that is tailored for a specific site’s experience. Yet, when “you’re looking for places to run an ad or creative that’s designed to run agnostically, you are no longer looking at specific experiences.”

The concept of programmatic advertising and its ability to scale ads and native, i.e., customized ads, Kim continued, “have natural tensions toward each other.” Despite the push toward automated native ads, the ad content must be more closely aligned with a publisher’s site. “You can’t say that achieving 100% automation is the only innovation that is needed,” she added. “New creative experiences also require more loving care.”

Brands and some publishers are beginning to churn out more content by building their own newsrooms (like Cisco’s Network or sponsored content sites like Forbes’ Brand Voices) but social media sites like Facebook, Twitter and Pinterest are better-positioned to leverage native ads by virtue of having a lot of user-generated content, according to Kim.

Brands also need to move fast. Native ads may be a better way to way to grab a reader’s attention, but we are quickly approaching a “tipping point” in which the novelty is wearing off, Xavier added. “There’s so much native out there that users are starting to get numb to it,” she said.

Must Read

Comic: Always Be Paddling

The Trade Desk Maintains Its High Growth Rate And Touts New Channels

“It’s hard not to be bullish about CTV when it’s both our largest channel and our fastest growing,” said The Trade Desk Founder and CEO Green during the company’s earnings report on Thursday.

After The Election, News Corp Has Harsh Words For Advertisers Who Avoided News

News Corp’s chief exec blasted “the blatant biases of ad agencies and ad associations,” which are “boycotting certain media properties” due to “personal political prejudices.”

LiveRamp Outperforms On Earnings And Lays Out Its Data Network Ambitions

LiveRamp reported an unexpected boost to Q3 revenue, from $160 million last year to $185 million in 2024, during its quarterly call with investors on Wednesday.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Google in the antitrust crosshairs (Law concept. Single line draw design. Full length animation illustration. High quality 4k footage)

Google And The DOJ Recap Their Cases In The Countdown To Closing Arguments

If you’re trying to read more than 1,000 pages of legal documents about the US v. Google ad tech antitrust case on Election Day, you’ve come to the right place.

NYT’s Ad And Subscription Revenue Surge As WaPo Flails

While WaPo recently lost 250,000 subscribers due to concerns over its journalistic independence, NYT added 260,000 subscriptions in Q3 thanks largely to the popularity of its non-news offerings.

Mark Proulx, global director of media quality & responsibility, Kenvue

How Kenvue Avoided $3 Million In Wasted Media Spend

Stop thinking about brand safety verification as “insurance” – a way to avoid undesirable content – and start thinking about it as an opportunity to build positive brand associations, says Kenvue’s Mark Proulx.