Home Digital TV and Video Videology, TubeMogul And The Trade Desk Top Forrester’s Video DSP Wave

Videology, TubeMogul And The Trade Desk Top Forrester’s Video DSP Wave

SHARE:

WaveWhen Forrester released its Wave assessment for video ad platforms Monday, the ability for each demand-side platform (DSP) to buy cross-screen – including linear TV – was a key factor.

“The biggest thing large advertisers are struggling with is how to use digital video and TV in combination, not just digital video by itself,” said Jim Nail, principal analyst at Forrester and the lead analyst for the report.

“Advertisers are really using video as a strong branding medium and buying and planning campaigns together with TV. We pushed these vendors to prove how well buys could complement each other.”

The surveying began last July, initially consisting of 40-50 video ad platforms. After a screening process that included a questionnaire with customers, demo and various discussions with the research house, Nail said the list was narrowed down to 10, including: AOL, DataXu, Google’s DoubleClick Bid Manager, The Trade Desk, Tremor Video, TubeMogul, Turn, Viant, Videology and Yahoo (BrightRoll).

Nail said each vendor was asked to execute a buy based on two factors: extending incremental reach on digital buys beyond the broad 18-49 demo usually associated with TV, and optimizing beyond the program schedule to recapture viewers that drop off from traditional TV viewing.

“Some of it was very quantitative – how many unique viewers can you reach in a month on all these different platforms and screens?” said Nail. “We asked for a list of all the data sources they could link into and which are integrated with the platform.”

Forrester then evaluated various measurements enabled by the platforms, all the way down to attribution and mix modeling capabilities.

 The Results

TubeMogul, Videology and The Trade Desk were leaders of the pack for various reasons.

TubeMogul scored strong ratings from customers both for its data sourcing and management capabilities. Because its main focus is the brand advertiser, its private marketplaces with some of the large TV networks allowed buyers to plan digital video campaigns alongside linear TV schedules.

Videology also optimizes reach and frequency across video and TV buys, though it focuses on serving both advertisers and publishers.

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

“There are several companies, such as Videology, who are trying to create a space that is not just DSP or SSP but more in the middle,” Nail said “Those who have the rationale that there’s an inherent conflict of interest if you try to serve both sides are met in the middle by those who believe you can work with both without taking a position in inventory. That’s setting up a real choice that the marketplace will have to shake out over the next couple of years.”

The Trade Desk’s inventory volume impressed Nail, and it received the highest customer satisfaction ratings “with good, solid segmenting, tracking and measurement of campaigns across the board,” he added.

Google was a “Strong Performer” despite being a “nonparticipating vendor,” meaning it participated in demos and discussions but didn’t share information around data integrations and measurement.

It was strong with in-flight optimization and could foreseeably benefit from Google’s bevy of first-party user data when unifying identities cross-screen. Additionally, its acquisition of video ad platform mDialog brings specialization in mobile and over-the-top video. “We’re certainly going to see things come together in the next year,” Nail said. “Google has had its eyes on TV for some time.”

Acquisitive Issues?

So what happened to Adap.tv and BrightRoll, the two video marketplaces/DSPs respectively acquired by AOL and Yahoo?

For one, both underwent brand changes – Adap.tv and AOL’s other video acquisitions are now part of One by AOL: Video. Nail noted AOL’s 30-some pubs like The Huffington Post and TechCrunch, as well as new parent Verizon’s deterministic data sets, portend more unique first-party implications for AOL’s video stack.

However, despite those advantages, AOL’s video offering scored lowest for customer satisfaction, suggesting the need for greater integration, which some have implied is not a new problem for AOL.

BrightRoll, too, has “a lot of catching up to do” with respect to integration, said Nail. While Yahoo’s DSP scored strong with customers on inventory availability, it earned lesser marks for its capability to support a converged video/TV plan.

“A technology transition takes a longer time than a brand transition,” Nail said, noting that some users expressed the need to smooth out functionality.

Must Read

Comic: Gamechanger (Google lost the DOJ's search antitrust case)

DOJ v. Google: How Judge Brinkema Seems To Be Thinking After Week One

Where the DOJ v. Google ad tech antitrust trial stands after one week’s worth of remedies arguments.

Swish, A Company That's Bringing Programmatic to Product Sampling, Announces Seed Funding

Swish, a startup that partners with retailers to provide product full-size CPG samples to people doing their grocery shopping online, announces $2.3 million in seed funding.

DOJ v. Google: During Opening Arguments, The DOJ And Google Battle Over An AdX Divestiture

Court is back in session. And the fate of  the open internet is in the balance.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Chris Mufarrige, director, Bureau of Consumer Protection, FTC

FTC Consumer Protection Chief: No Easy Answers On Privacy, ‘Only Trade-Offs’

Privacy isn’t black-and-white, says the FTC’s Chris Mufarrige, promising evidence-driven consumer protection cases under the Trump administration.

How Encryption Keys Could Resolve The TID Furor

Rather than sharing universal TIDs that any DSP or curator can access, Raptive says publishers should instead share encrypted TIDs with an encryption key provided only to trusted demand-side partners.

Clear Channel Brings Mid-Flight Measurement To Its OOH Network

Clear Channel will provide advertisers weekly, mid-flight reports on outcomes driven by its inventory in order to bring OOH measurement closer to the speed of digital.