Home Data-Driven Thinking Private Exchanges Aren’t Immune To Ad Fraud

Private Exchanges Aren’t Immune To Ad Fraud

SHARE:

andrew-pancer“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Andrew Pancer, chief operating officer at Dstillery.

I attended the AdExchanger Clean Ads conference in New York last month. Overall, the presentations were good, but I took some issue with certain points of view on the “dangers” of buying on open exchanges.

Some recommendations were made on stage encouraging marketers to stop blindly relying on open exchanges and instead establish direct-to-publisher relationships. It was also suggested that marketers should enable private exchanges as a means to guard against fraud.

While I agree that marketers need to be diligent about the inventory they buy and that direct publisher relationships are a good thing, I disagree with a few of the statements presented.

Private Exchanges Are Not The Solution To Combat Ad Fraud

Private exchanges help marketers to meet strategic objectives by efficiently working directly with specific publishers. They help publishers achieve higher inventory rates versus open exchanges or other remnant strategies. Private exchanges are not, however, a fraud-prevention solution.

All things considered, private exchanges typically have lower levels of fraud than open exchanges, but they are not immune from contagion. Integral Ad Science’s Q1 2015 Media Quality Report measures publisher fraud levels at 4% of traffic.

ad-fraud

Source: Integral Ad Science Media Quality Report – Q1 2015

There are two main causes of private exchange fraud. The first is aggressive audience acquisition. Many large publishers promise audience levels that they can’t achieve organically, leading them to acquire traffic, much of which is non-human, driven by bots. The second cause is that botnets generate traffic on legitimate sites to make them look real and to throw fraud-detection services off of their scent.

The Inclusion Of Open Exchanges Enhances Audience Targeting

Open exchanges, while infected with a higher level of fraud – 16.5% per the same report – are an important component of the Internet ecosystem. They have an abundance of great inventory, ranging from name-brand publishers to obscure long-tail sites. Characterizing the open exchanges as havens for fraud is harmful to the good actors who rely on programmatic advertising to support and grow their businesses.

Further, participating in private exchanges to the exclusion of open exchanges will damage scale and performance of advertising campaigns. Marketers tend to focus on finding scarce events, such as a conversion. Open exchanges allow advertisers to reach large groups of more finely targeted audiences. When an addressable audience pool is materially restricted, the marketer will have a difficult time achieving its desired scale and performance.

The best way to navigate the use of open exchanges is to understand how your vendor partners combat fraud. If you use a demand-side platform (DSP), how do they eliminate fraud in all environments? How do they go beyond the basic blacklist? If you are a DSP, ask your exchange partners, both open and private, what they are doing to stop botnet traffic in all areas of their business. With the right strategy and focus, fraud on open exchange inventory can be minimized to the same levels as private exchanges or even buying directly from publishers.

The Clean Ads conference was focused on cleaning up the digital marketing ecosystem. As an industry we should strive to support and strengthen a healthy and scalable solution for our clients. Hiding behind private exchange walls is not the solution. Investing in fraud-detection/elimination technology and building a sophisticated alert system that works across open and private exchanges is. By doing so, we provide brand marketers a real solution to get their message in front of desired audiences at scale.

Follow Dstillery (@dstillery) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Tagged in:

Must Read

WPP’s Angela Steele On AI, CTV And The ‘Trusted Growth Partner’ Pitch

AI is taking over the media and tech industries in the name of simplification, and marketers are pining for provable campaign outcomes, including from TV. These shifts are also causing significant change in Agency Holdco Land, according to Angela Steele, the first chief client officer for WPP Media US.

Shopify Noses Further Into Ad Tech With Campaign Autopilot Expansion

No major retail media player has taken as circumspect an approach to ad revenue as Shopify. But the company has recently taken its next important step with a product called Campaign Autopilot.

Benji Shomair, VP of monetization, OpenAI & Terry Kawaja, CEO, LUMA Partners (photo credit: Jenna Bascom Photography / LUMA Partners)

In OpenAI’s Ad Business, Advertisers Come Third

OpenAI’s head of monetization, Benji Shomair makes the case for ads as a way to bring ChatGPT to more people, with user trust taking priority over advertiser demands.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

The Trade Desk’s Revenue Slipped In Q3. If It Wants To Grow, It Must Evolve

In Q3, The Trade Desk beat the admittedly pessimistic revenue forecast it set for itself earlier this year. But growth has stalled.

Human artist painting on canvas, while beside him an AI robot stands copying the artwork onto its own canvas. Depict the controversy surrounding Generative AI and the creativity of human artists

Viant Buys Waymark For $20 Million, Because CTV Needs More Ads (More!)

Viant is doubling down on CTV with its $20 million Waymark acquisition, betting that AI-generated ads can bring more advertisers to streaming TV.

Smart AI Chatbot Virtual Assistant Vector Icon design

TIME’s AI Agents Do The Coordinating, And Its Sellers Still Do The Selling

TIME is using AI agents to draft proposals and troubleshoot campaigns – but not to replace the human relationships that drive ad sales.