Home Podcast A World Without One-to-One Targeting

A World Without One-to-One Targeting

SHARE:

Subscribe to AdExchanger Talks on iTunes, Google Play, Spotify, Stitcher, SoundCloud or wherever you listen to podcasts.

Was it just three days ago that Google Chrome told the world that come 2022, it would block third-party cookies by default? Already a tsunami of coverage and analyses has resulted, much of it wondering about the negative fallout for addressable advertising.

This week on AdExchanger Talks, Belinda Smith provides the bull case for a world without universal addressability.

“When we got, I would argue, as close as we are probably going to get to one-to-one, I didn’t see any company that had unleashed itself and 10x’d its valuation because of the one-to-one addressable market,” she says. “I started in programmatic 10 years ago, and I thought then and think now that it’s very exciting, but it’s not the only thing. There are people in this industry who don’t know anything else. And I think that’s super problematic because we are ignoring 90% of marketing, which is everything that’s not addressable.”

Smith argues that the real value of one-to-one has still not been proven out in any ROI calculations she has seen firsthand.

“We didn’t hear a lot about what went right for marketers with [programmatic],” she says. “We talk a lot about the value of one-to-one, and I think what’s missing in that equation are the technologies and the people needed to make that happen. So when we talk about optimizing around 5 million different campaign lines globally … is it worth it? Can someone do it effectively? How do you QA that? When we talk about, for every lat-long point of interest I can have different creative, yeah you could! But how much did it cost? How many people did you need to run that? And how long did it take you to do that? Put all of that into your ROI calculation and tell me was it worth it?”

Must Read

In 2019, Google moved to a first-price auction and also ceded its last look advantage in AdX, in part because it had to. Most exchanges had already moved to first price.

Unraveling The Mystery Of PubMatic’s $5 Million Loss From A “First-Price Auction Switch”

PubMatic’s $5 million loss from DV360’s bidding algorithm fix earlier this year suggests second-price auctions aren’t completely a thing of the past.

A comic version of former News Corp executive Stephanie Layser in the courtroom for the DOJ's ad tech-focused trial against Google in Virginia.

The DOJ vs. Google, Day Two: Tales From The Underbelly Of Ad Tech

Day Two of the Google antitrust trial in Alexandria, Virginia on Tuesday was just as intensely focused on the intricacies of ad tech as on Day One.

A comic depicting Judge Leonie Brinkema's view of the her courtroom where the DOJ vs. Google ad tech antitrust trial is about to begin. (Comic: Court Is In Session)

Your Day One Recap: DOJ vs. Google Goes Deep Into The Ad Tech Weeds

It’s not often one gets to hear sworn witnesses in federal court explain the intricacies of header bidding under oath. But that’s what happened during the first day of the Google ad tech-focused antitrust case in Virginia on Monday.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Comic: What Else? (Google, Jedi Blue, Project Bernanke)

Project Cheat Sheet: A Rundown On All Of Google’s Secret Internal Projects, As Revealed By The DOJ

What do Hercule Poirot, Ben Bernanke, Star Wars and C.S. Lewis have in common? If you’re an ad tech nerd, you’ll know the answer immediately.

shopping cart

The Wonderful Brand Discusses Testing OOH And Online Snack Competition

Wonderful hadn’t done an out-of-home (OOH) marketing push in more than 15 years. That is, until a week ago, when it began a campaign across six major markets to promote its new no-shell pistachio packs.

Google filed a motion to exclude the testimony of any government witnesses who aren’t economists or antitrust experts during the upcoming ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.

Google Is Fighting To Keep Ad Tech Execs Off the Stand In Its Upcoming Antitrust Trial

Google doesn’t want AppNexus founder Brian O’Kelley – you know, the godfather of programmatic – to testify during its ad tech antitrust trial starting on September 9.