Home Data-Driven Thinking A Reality Check On The AI Revolution: Ecommerce Still Needs A Human Touch

A Reality Check On The AI Revolution: Ecommerce Still Needs A Human Touch

SHARE:
Catherine Leung, managing executive director, head of activation, Hearts & Science.

Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Catherine Leung, managing executive director, head of activation, Hearts & Science.

As ecommerce continues to boom, AI technology promises to revolutionize nearly every aspect of a retailer’s operations. At the same time, products frequently explode overnight thanks to unforeseen TikTok movements or the whims of digital creators – something that’s almost impossible for machines to anticipate. 

Never before have technology and data played such a powerful role in driving what people purchase. Yet, the human aspect of tastemaking has never had more influence.

This paradoxical reality is a stark reminder that, even as retailers move to embrace automation, the need for human oversight and decision-making can’t be overstated or overlooked. The key to success for businesses will lie in determining where AI and machine learning will have the most meaningful impact and recognizing what machines can’t do.

AI’s advertising promise

AI can accelerate commerce in many meaningful ways. It can scale any data-driven process, provide predictions based on patterns and make informed recommendations based on a variety of insights and data sources. Below are just four areas where it can have a significant impact for advertisers: 

1. Demand dynamics: The right technology can help retailers understand demand dynamics at scale, parse how audiences around the world react to external trends and uncover related behaviors that might not be intuitive. Currently, demand planning is the most widely used machine learning application in the supply chain. But going forward, AI promises to benefit replenishment timing and retailer commitments, too.

2. Supply needs: As the pandemic has taught us, machines are much better than people when it comes to monitoring sales and supply chains. It can anticipate needs before problems arise.

3. Inventory management: Algorithms excel at helping companies monitor what is currently on their shelves, what’s available in the warehouse, what needs to go where and how long it will take to get there. Connecting live inventory to relevant offers and promotions is only possible when you know where your products are in real time. Automation can create symmetry between demand and available products.  

4. Paid media: The combination of programmatic ads and behavioral and sentiment data is a potent way for brands to push the right products and offers to the most receptive audiences in moments of intent. Machine learning has the power to drive incrementality through tactics like audience segmentation modeling and dynamic creative optimization. But success requires a solid foundation of inputs (e.g., strong creative and messaging) from which to augment.

Humans at the helm

Despite the potential of AI to transform many areas of business, managing a commerce business still requires skilled experts to mind the store, so to speak. While models are valuable for brands when planning and making decisions, even the most sophisticated retailers need a human to determine where opportunities for refinement – or even innovation – lie.

1. Humans must connect the dots: AI will never be a set-it-and-forget-it solution. The dirty secret of AI-powered ecommerce today is that, while many solutions pitch themselves as one-stop shops, they are actually point solutions that create silos. Connecting these systems is a big lift and requires human judgment.

2. Tastemaking and culture can’t be replicated by machines: It’s dangerous to extrapolate any trend over time. The “new normal” keeps changing, and people are inherently unpredictable. When it comes to shopping, there will always be a very human desire to curate one’s life – and tastemaking isn’t something easily fed into an algorithm.

As brands examine which parts of their business lend themselves to employing software and algorithms and which don’t, it’s crucial to dispel the notion that a single AI solution is possible – or even desirable. When making choices about where to place bets, retailers must assess what can be automated and what requires human oversight. Additionally, they must assess which aspects can be handled internally and which areas will require outside help to orchestrate.

As software promises to bring massive scale and efficiency to ecommerce by unlocking demand, shopping is still fundamentally about brands. Tomorrow’s leading commerce players will be the ones that strike the right balance between automation and human touch.

Follow Hearts & Science (@hearts_science) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

Omnicom Investors Cheer IPG Sell-Off, Despite Weak Ad Spend In Q2

Omnicom is halfway through a major sell-off of IPG agencies. Its future looks healthier as it prunes lower-growth firms, including eliminating certain specialist firms and overlapping agencies in certain countries.

Hundreds of emails, depositions and other documents have been unsealed in the lead-up to the Google antitrust trial, providing a fascinating look at how Google talked about its own products when no one else was watching – especially tools to counteract the rise of header bidding.

Why PubMatic Ditched Its Prebid Web Wrapper, But Never Its SDK

Earlier this month, PubMatic shelved its Prebid integration wrapper, known as OpenWrap Web, and announced it would begin recommending Playwire as an offloading-onboarding partner for the 250-odd publishers that use its wrapper.

Gareth Glaser, Co-Founder & CEO, Gamera

Google’s Buyer Direct Could Beat Agentic Ad Tech At Its Own Game

Agentic AI shows promise for direct deals. But if Google has its way, Buyer Direct could put an end to all sorts of agentic direct sales opportunities while they’re still in the cradle.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

How Warner Bros. Discovery Is Creating Value Out Of Dead Air With Pause Ads

Streaming publishers are banking on pause ads to bolster revenue with a more user-friendly ad experience. With programmatic standardization still pending, Warner Bros. Discovery is taking a stab at advancing the capabilities behind its own pause ad formats.

Peacock Hits Profitability As Comcast Prepares To Spin Off NBCU

Peacock hit what Comcast Co-CEO Mike Cavanagh called “meaningful profitability” for the first time in Q2, just as Comcast decided to let it leave the nest. 

Comic: It's Coming For You

Programmatic Platforms Champion Transparency, But Not If It Means Giving Activists Access

A DSP refused to give ad industry watchdog Check My Ads a seat on its platform, even after both parties cosigned a master service agreement, citing concerns about “protections” for “vendor and supply partners.”