Home CTV Roundup This Year’s Upfront Results Showcase Netflix’s Lack Of Transparency

This Year’s Upfront Results Showcase Netflix’s Lack Of Transparency

SHARE:

Netflix showed off impressive numbers coming out of its upfront negotiations last week. But the ad industry remains less-than-impressed with Netflix’s lack of transparency.

During its second-ever upfront, Netflix says it saw 150% year-over-year growth in commitments. But the streamer declined to share dollar amounts or specific percentages regarding where its commitments came from or what they’re earmarked for. Netflix also didn’t offer a base number for its upfront commitments last year, making it nearly impossible to put the reported growth in perspective.

This lack of transparency – and believe me, I did ask for a number – sparked a somewhat heated discussion on LinkedIn. The conversation, started by Evan Shapiro, a self-described “media universe cartographer,” stemmed from AdExchanger’s recent coverage of Netflix’s upfront results.

When publicly traded companies tout such significant growth, they “must be transparent and include the supporting points,” Sandra Lopez, an investor and media vet, wrote in response to the post.

Amazon also just announced the close of its first-ever upfront. The ecommerce giant didn’t disclose a dollar amount of commitments or its CPMs.

Meanwhile, NBCUniversal, Disney, Warner Bros. Discovery and Paramount announced consistent year-over-year growth with a jump in commitments for streaming in particular. Unlike Netflix, the broadcasters also highlighted specific percentages of growth for sports, multicultural programming and investments from small and midsize businesses (SMBs).

The Netflix walled garden

Despite the industry critiques over Netflix’s lack of transparency, the streamer is fortifying its garden walls and further limiting the amount of information it shares publicly about its nascent advertising business.

In April, for example, Netflix shared that it will no longer report quarterly subscriber numbers starting next year. Naturally, that decision sparked doubt over subscriber growth for the platform’s ad-supported tier, introduced in late 2022. As of May, Netflix had 40 million monthly active users, which are individual profiles within a smaller (and undisclosed) number of paying household accounts.

Considering Netflix’s protectiveness over its subscriber numbers, it’s unsurprising that Netflix’s upfront results announcement is also opaque.

While ad sales growth of 150% sounds impressive, Netflix is only in its second year of selling ads, so it’s not yet a mature business with consistent year-over-year growth. Plus, without any hard numbers, there’s almost no way to know how this growth translates into actual ad dollars.

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

The more important number to pay attention to is Netflix’s CPMs, according to media and agency vet Danny Weisman, writing in response to Shapiro’s original LinkedIn post. Earlier this month, Netflix dropped its CPMs to just under $30, down from between $39 and $45 last year. The new prices are a far cry from the $65 CPMs Netflix was charging when it first launched ads in 2022.

Lower prices may dilute the overall value Netflix is getting from the upfront deals it recently closed, Weisman wrote.

Netflix had to lower its CPMs to compete with other digital giants, namely Amazon’s Prime Video, which defaulted its subscribers to ads earlier this year. Prime Video has roughly 200 million US subscribers with CPMs hovering around $30.

Netflix may be Netflix – as in, a byword for premium – but most media buyers making upfront commitments are also looking for platforms with scale, competitive pricing and transparency.

Broadcasters brandish their numbers

In contrast, legacy broadcasters like Disney, NBCU, WBD and Paramount are providing more transparency into their upfront deals to prove they can excel where Netflix lags: scale.

NBCU boasted that its content portfolio reaches 273 million people each month, representing a far bigger audience for advertisers than Netflix.

As for ad sales growth, NBCU has seen a consistent 40% increase in demand year-over-year for the past three years. Disney’s streaming ad commitments rose 10% since last year, and for WBD’s streaming service Max, that number was 50%. In Paramount’s case, it boasted $1 billion in spend commitments specifically for streaming.

Although most programmers didn’t share specific dollar amounts for their commitments this year, similar to Netflix, they at least shared percentages or ranges that highlight specific growth areas, which Netflix did not.

Sports was also a bragging point for these four broadcasters. NBCU, Disney and WBD all announced double-digit percentage growth in commitments for sports. Netflix also highlighted its deals for live events, such as WWE Raw and the Christmas Day NFL games.

NBCU shared more information specifically regarding small and midsize advertisers, which most programmers are trying to win over with easy-to-use self-serve ad platforms. NBCU’s SMB growth division grew 50% since last year, and within that group, ad investments in sports jumped 90%.

Netflix, on the other hand, shared no specifics regarding spend commitments for sports or from SMBs.

It certainly pays to be transparent. But the question I still have is this: Will transparency be enough to help legacy broadcasters win the streaming wars against Netflix?

Update 9/03/24: This story has been updated to include Amazon’s upfront close.

Must Read

The Trade Desk Maintains Its High Growth Rate And Touts New Channels

“It’s hard not to be bullish about CTV when it’s both our largest channel and our fastest growing,” said The Trade Desk Founder and CEO Green during the company’s earnings report on Thursday.

After The Election, News Corp Has Harsh Words For Advertisers Who Avoided News

News Corp’s chief exec blasted “the blatant biases of ad agencies and ad associations,” which are “boycotting certain media properties” due to “personal political prejudices.”

LiveRamp Outperforms On Earnings And Lays Out Its Data Network Ambitions

LiveRamp reported an unexpected boost to Q3 revenue, from $160 million last year to $185 million in 2024, during its quarterly call with investors on Wednesday.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Google in the antitrust crosshairs (Law concept. Single line draw design. Full length animation illustration. High quality 4k footage)

Google And The DOJ Recap Their Cases In The Countdown To Closing Arguments

If you’re trying to read more than 1,000 pages of legal documents about the US v. Google ad tech antitrust case on Election Day, you’ve come to the right place.

NYT’s Ad And Subscription Revenue Surge As WaPo Flails

While WaPo recently lost 250,000 subscribers due to concerns over its journalistic independence, NYT added 260,000 subscriptions in Q3 thanks largely to the popularity of its non-news offerings.

Mark Proulx, global director of media quality & responsibility, Kenvue

How Kenvue Avoided $3 Million In Wasted Media Spend

Stop thinking about brand safety verification as “insurance” – a way to avoid undesirable content – and start thinking about it as an opportunity to build positive brand associations, says Kenvue’s Mark Proulx.