Home Data-Driven Thinking Turning Off A Supply Source Is More Complicated Than It Seems
OPINION: Data-Driven Thinking

Turning Off A Supply Source Is More Complicated Than It Seems

By AdExchanger

SHARE:

“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Michael Berkowitz, solutions architect at Jounce Media.

In the age of supply-path optimization (SPO), marketers are more deeply evaluating how their bids reach publishers, and many brands and agencies are working to establish strategic alliances with a short list of trusted ad exchanges.

Due to the ongoing COVID-19 crisis that is shaking up the industry, the cost savings benefits of these strategic alliances have become even more important. Marketers benefit from reduced sell-side fees in return for agreeing to bid into five to 10 exchanges and turning off the rest.

But “turning off the rest” is harder than it seems.

Unchecking the box

In every demand-side platform (DSP) user interface, there is a collection of ad exchange checkboxes that allow the marketer to control where its bids are submitted.

Let’s say, for example, that a marketer decides to disable bidding into Unruly. (This is not necessarily an SPO choice I would recommend, but it serves as a useful example.) Unchecking the DSP’s “Unruly” button prevents the marketer’s campaigns from responding to bid requests from Unruly:

Unruly's supply path

But it turns out that isn’t the only way the marketer’s bids reach Unruly. There are actually four different supply paths that connect DSP bids to the Unruly auction:

Unruly supply path is more complicated than it seems.

Index Exchange, AppNexus and Rubicon Project all act as authorized resellers of the Unruly auction. There are good reasons why these reselling relationships exist. But those reselling supply paths make it operationally difficult for a marketer to stop participating in Unruly auctions. In most DSPs, unchecking the “Unruly” button disables bidding into the blue path, but not the red ones. The marketer who intended to disable Unruly continues to participate in those auctions, but now only through multihop paths.

Path-level blacklisting

Disabling all bidding into the Unruly auction requires the marketer to implement path-level bidding rules that reject bid requests from the following three ads.txt entries:

appnexus.com, 6849, RESELLER
indexexchange.com, 182257, RESELLER
rubiconproject.com, 15268, RESELLER

Now expand this challenge to dozens of additional programmatic marketplaces that marketers might want to disable as part of a broader SPO initiative. To disable Sovrn, they’ll need to also disable these supply paths:

appnexus.com, 1019, RESELLER
appnexus.com, 1360, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 558511, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 560360, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 560621, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 560961, RESELLER
gumgum.com, 11645, RESELLER
openx.com, 537103367, RESELLER
openx.com, 537120960, RESELLER
openx.com, 538959099, RESELLER
openx.com, 539620057, RESELLER
openx.com, 539924617, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 137711, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156212, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156700, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 157595, RESELLER
rubiconproject.com, 15380, RESELLER
rubiconproject.com, 17960, RESELLER
smartadserver.com, 2923, RESELLER

Want to disable Verizon Media? They better make sure they disable all these Verizon resellers:

appnexus.com, 1226, RESELLER
appnexus.com, 1868, RESELLER
appnexus.com, 273, RESELLER
appnexus.com, 3292, RESELLER
appnexus.com, 3663, RESELLER
brealtime.com, 1246, RESELLER
brealtime.com, 273, RESELLER
brealtime.com, 485, RESELLER
brealtime.com, 72, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 558299, RESELLER
contextweb.com, 561707, RESELLER
indexexchange.com, 175407, RESELLER
indexexchange.com, 183875, RESELLER
indexexchange.com, 183965, RESELLER
indexexchange.com, 184110, RESELLER
openx.com, 537125356, RESELLER
openx.com, 537126269, RESELLER
openx.com, 537143344, RESELLER
openx.com, 539959224, RESELLER
openx.com, 540236670, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 133799, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 155967, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156078, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156084, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156138, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156139, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156140, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156248, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156325, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156377, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156458, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156530, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156556, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156674, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 156971, RESELLER
pubmatic.com, 158430, RESELLER
rubiconproject.com, 17250, RESELLER
rubiconproject.com, 18222, RESELLER
spot.im, 266658, RESELLER
xad.com, 240, RESELLER

Fully disabling nonpreferred exchanges might require the marketer to blacklist hundreds or even thousands of supply paths.

Thankfully, many DSPs now properly support this path-level bidding control. And open source tools such as our free supply path database make it easy for marketers to comprehensively identify resold inventory that does not meet their SPO strategy. Savvy marketers have all the tools they need to encode their preferred exchange partnerships into precise bidding rules.

Getting to perfect

Path-level blacklisting goes a long way to allowing marketers to stop bidding into nonpreferred supply sources, but it isn’t a perfect solution. The programmatic supply landscape is littered with value-extracting three-hop and four-hop supply paths that might continue to lead a marketer to auctions that it wants to disable.

There are emerging solutions to address the challenges of multihop supply paths, most notably the RTB SupplyChain (schain) object. The schain object, provided by the exchange, allows buyers to see the full chain of payment hops between the DSP and the publisher. And with this information, marketers and their DSPs are armed to disable bidding into long supply paths that lead to nonpreferred exchanges.

We’re optimistic that both sell-side and buy-side technology companies will more actively support the SupplyChain object. But for now, we think path-level blacklisting is a robust solution that allows most marketers to achieve their SPO goals.

Follow Jounce Media (@jouncemedia) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Tagged in:

Must Read

Gaming

Unity And Index Exchange Unite Behind Gaming Data In Non-Gaming Channels

For the first time, Unity’s gaming audiences will be available for ad targeting outside the Unity platform, with Index Exchange using Unity’s data to curate web and CTV inventory.

AI

Brand-Trained Agents Can Give Marketers A Fuller View Of Their Customers

Agentic commerce company Envive builds on-site agents for brands like footwear company Clove, painting a clearer picture of what their customers are looking for.

CTV

Don’t Worry About Netflix – It’s Doing Fine Without Warner Bros. Discovery

Paramount might have outlasted and outbid Netflix in the competition to acquire Warner Bros. Discovery, but Netflix is not overly fussed about the loss.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
CTV

Paramount’s Upfront Pitch Is About Three Things

Paramount is merging the ad tech stacks behind Paramount+ and Pluto TV, releasing a new performance product, offering more control over ad placements and introducing dynamic ad insertion in live sports.

Marketers

Hard Truths For Retail Media At The IAB Connected Commerce Summit

The IAB’s Connected Commerce event in New York City this week felt to me like the retail media industry’s first sit-down explanation to a child who is now a “big kid” and must act accordingly.

Platforms

Meta Is Launching An Easy Button For CAPI

Meta is simplifying its CAPI setup and teaching its pixel new tricks, including adding an AI-powered feature that automatically pulls in data from an advertiser’s website.

Popular

  1. Seattle, WA USA - circa February 2023: Close up view of Liquid Death sparkling water for sale inside a grocery store
    Measurement

    Liquid Death Lets Incrementality Decide What Tactics To Kill And What To Keep

    Behind its edgy marketing, Liquid Death faces a familiar CPG problem: Most sales happen at the register, where media measurement goes to die.

  2. Frans Vermeulen, Co-Founder & President, Swivel
    OPINION: On TV & Video

    Why CTV Is Becoming The First Real Test Of Agentic Advertising

    CTV never fit cleanly into campaign execution models built for RTB-based trading. Whether agentic AI solutions can simplify the complicated CTV landscape for publishers will be their first real test case.

  3. programmatic transparency

    The Tech Lab’s New Programmatic Governance Council Is So Over All The Ad Tech Drama

    A new IAB Tech Lab group is working on ground rules for the very unruly $200 billion programmatic ad market. Godspeed!

  4. The periscopes have eyes.
    Data Privacy Roundup

    Why A 1967 Privacy Law Is Powering A New Wave Of Ad Tech Lawsuits

    If you want to see a privacy lawyer who works in ad tech roll their eyes and heave a deep sigh, then speak aloud this acronym: “CIPA.”

  5. Don Marti, Principal, Aloodo LLC
    OPINION: Data-Driven Thinking

    What Happens When The Attribution Cartel Meets Advertising’s Halo Effect?

    A proposed standard under discussion at W3C aims to redefine how ad effectiveness is measured across the web. This proposal would centralize measurement of ad effectiveness under the control of Google, Apple and Meta.