Home Data-Driven Thinking Marketers Deserve Complete Transparency About Exchange Fees

Marketers Deserve Complete Transparency About Exchange Fees

SHARE:

“Data-Driven Thinking” is written by members of the media community and contains fresh ideas on the digital revolution in media.

Today’s column is written by Dhawal Mujumdar, co-founder at Polymorph.

To combat domain fraud, ads.txt was implemented as a tool for publishers to disclose which exchanges are authorized to sell their inventory. Why don’t we have a similar system where fees are clearly disclosed in every bid request so buyers know how much of their spend is going toward middlemen fees vs. actual marketing media?

Why not have some initiative, like ads.cert, which is in beta for OpenRTB 3.0, for pricing and take rates that are clearly baked into OpenRTB protocol? That way, marketers and demand-side platforms can choose the cheapest route to reach their desired audiences.

This would eventually lead toward a much more reasonable fee structure where more revenue would pass from marketer to publisher. It would also lead to innovation in ad tech business models and come closer to the kind of transparency found in stock exchanges, which many hold up as an aspirational model for ad tech.

Securities such as stocks, bonds and other financial instruments are traded in stock market exchanges to raise capital for businesses and create investment opportunities, with the exchange acting as a clearing house. Ad exchanges are similar, but instead of securities, we are trading media and conducting auctions.

However, ad exchanges radically differ from stock exchanges in their business models and transparency. Almost all major stock exchanges have very clear and transparent business models: They charge participants for listing fees, data and information services, technology solutions and transactional fees. For example, the New York Stock Exchange has a clearly defined fee structure, which is openly disclosed on its website and in financial reports.

Most ad exchanges, while similar in function, operate on the transactional revenue alone in the form of take rates, which are not always disclosed to all the participants, especially buyers. Buyers are mainly left to figure out how much of their spend is really going toward buying media vs. ad tech exchange fees. Take rates are a contentious issue, with recent price wars. Many exchanges have dynamic take rates that change on impression-to-impression basis. All of this leads to non-transparent behavior, which leads to questionable tactics such as bid caching or hidden fees.

It took the watershed moment of a stock market crash in 1929 to pass the Securities Act of 1933, which eventually led to establishment of the Securities and Exchange Commission to provide transparency and disclosure in the securities-trading world. Financial stock markets are not perfect but at least they are much more transparent.

We are at that pivotal moment in digital advertising where trust is at an all-time low, the industry is fraught with fragmentation, fraud is eating the business inside out and yet billions of dollars are traded every day. It’s time for ad tech to pick up the pace. Viewability standards and ads.txt started the ball rolling, but let’s increase the momentum by incorporating more measures that improve transparency.

Follow Polymorph (@polymorphlabs) and AdExchanger (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

WPP’s Angela Steele On AI, CTV And The ‘Trusted Growth Partner’ Pitch

AI is taking over the media and tech industries in the name of simplification, and marketers are pining for provable campaign outcomes, including from TV. These shifts are also causing significant change in Agency Holdco Land, according to Angela Steele, the first chief client officer for WPP Media US.

Shopify Noses Further Into Ad Tech With Campaign Autopilot Expansion

No major retail media player has taken as circumspect an approach to ad revenue as Shopify. But the company has recently taken its next important step with a product called Campaign Autopilot.

Benji Shomair, VP of monetization, OpenAI & Terry Kawaja, CEO, LUMA Partners (photo credit: Jenna Bascom Photography / LUMA Partners)

In OpenAI’s Ad Business, Advertisers Come Third

OpenAI’s head of monetization, Benji Shomair makes the case for ads as a way to bring ChatGPT to more people, with user trust taking priority over advertiser demands.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

The Trade Desk’s Revenue Slipped In Q3. If It Wants To Grow, It Must Evolve

In Q3, The Trade Desk beat the admittedly pessimistic revenue forecast it set for itself earlier this year. But growth has stalled.

Human artist painting on canvas, while beside him an AI robot stands copying the artwork onto its own canvas. Depict the controversy surrounding Generative AI and the creativity of human artists

Viant Buys Waymark For $20 Million, Because CTV Needs More Ads (More!)

Viant is doubling down on CTV with its $20 million Waymark acquisition, betting that AI-generated ads can bring more advertisers to streaming TV.

Smart AI Chatbot Virtual Assistant Vector Icon design

TIME’s AI Agents Do The Coordinating, And Its Sellers Still Do The Selling

TIME is using AI agents to draft proposals and troubleshoot campaigns – but not to replace the human relationships that drive ad sales.