Home The Sell Sider A Publisher View on Real-Time Bidding Today

A Publisher View on Real-Time Bidding Today

SHARE:

Tyler Fitch“The Sell-Sider” is a column written by the sell-side of the digital media community.

Tyler Fitch is Director of Yield Management at Mindjolt, an online games company.

The following has been building up for months after seeing article after article of DSP execs saying that publishers are wrong and should open up their all their inventory to RTB while there’s little public pushback from the sell-side community.  It’s like the Oil Industry telling the public that they should all go out and buy a brand new Hummer.

It’s 100% in the DSP’s best interest for Publishers to open up their entire inventory to RTB and might not be in best interest of the publisher. Now I am not saying not to use exchanges, I am actually a huge advocate of them.  RTB allows the publisher to show the right ad at the right time but RTB also allows us not to be rewarded for showing relevant ads. Publishers need to know how RTB can help or hurt their revenue streams.

As a sell-side operations executive, the main problems I have with RTB are as follows:

  1. Almost all DSP’s buy on a Dynamic CPM in a Second Priced Auction.  This feature is strictly-buy side focused as it always lets advertisers only pay 1 cent more than they have to, even though the impression might be worth much more to the advertiser. Buying through RTB allows the DSP to squeeze margins for themselves and/or their clients.
  2. RTB does NOT scale (yet).  Having dynamically-bidded inventory in a supply heavy environment creates problems for the publisher.  For example, let’s say that RTB buys 40% of my inventory, but in a second price auction there needs to be two bids to actually be beneficial to a publisher.  So, in the end, the publisher only actually gains revenue from maybe 20+% of the total RTB bidded impressions because it has two or more competing bids.  Not to mention that the other half of the RTB impressions with one bid takes the high performing impressions that would go to  performance and traditional networks which lowers performance and drives down CPM’s.  Eventually this gives the Dcpm buyers access to even cheaper inventory as prices are driven down.

Another mistake I have seen publishers make with RTB is not accounting for impression loss or discrepancy.  In my experience, about a 10% loss in impressions occurs per server hop.  So if a publisher is running RTB through another 3rd party ad server and letting the DSP’s “cherry pick”, they lose a percentage of traffic on the first ad call, and another percentage if they pass the impression back.  Throw in a SSP’s cut and you can be losing up to 25 to 40% before the first dollar is made.

Pubs, please get an ad server with an exchange already built-in and make sure that you use it correctly! Not only does it create a proper auction but allows the publisher to game the system.  I wrote an article about this last year (read more).

On “Data Leakage”, I actually side with the DSP’s.  This might vary from pub to pub depending on the value of the audience, but I think the more data the better.  First-party data and Context is king, but if for example, Peer39 (a semantic data provider) knows that one of my users is a “Left Handed Grandma that likes Basketball” and a DSP has demand to back it up… go for it!

So what is the long term solution for Publishers?  There really isn’t one, and that’s the problem.  RTB is here to stay and publishers need the tools to extract value and break Dpcm arbitrage. Until then, publishers will be slow to adopt the technology.

Follow Tyler Fitch (@tylerwfitch) and AdExchanger.com (@adexchanger) on Twitter.

Must Read

WPP’s Angela Steele On AI, CTV And The ‘Trusted Growth Partner’ Pitch

AI is taking over the media and tech industries in the name of simplification, and marketers are pining for provable campaign outcomes, including from TV. These shifts are also causing significant change in Agency Holdco Land, according to Angela Steele, the first chief client officer for WPP Media US.

Shopify Noses Further Into Ad Tech With Campaign Autopilot Expansion

No major retail media player has taken as circumspect an approach to ad revenue as Shopify. But the company has recently taken its next important step with a product called Campaign Autopilot.

Benji Shomair, VP of monetization, OpenAI & Terry Kawaja, CEO, LUMA Partners (photo credit: Jenna Bascom Photography / LUMA Partners)

In OpenAI’s Ad Business, Advertisers Come Third

OpenAI’s head of monetization, Benji Shomair makes the case for ads as a way to bring ChatGPT to more people, with user trust taking priority over advertiser demands.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

The Trade Desk’s Revenue Slipped In Q3. If It Wants To Grow, It Must Evolve

In Q3, The Trade Desk beat the admittedly pessimistic revenue forecast it set for itself earlier this year. But growth has stalled.

Human artist painting on canvas, while beside him an AI robot stands copying the artwork onto its own canvas. Depict the controversy surrounding Generative AI and the creativity of human artists

Viant Buys Waymark For $20 Million, Because CTV Needs More Ads (More!)

Viant is doubling down on CTV with its $20 million Waymark acquisition, betting that AI-generated ads can bring more advertisers to streaming TV.

Smart AI Chatbot Virtual Assistant Vector Icon design

TIME’s AI Agents Do The Coordinating, And Its Sellers Still Do The Selling

TIME is using AI agents to draft proposals and troubleshoot campaigns – but not to replace the human relationships that drive ad sales.