Home Agencies PROG I/O: Advertisers Seek Guidance In Programmatic

PROG I/O: Advertisers Seek Guidance In Programmatic

SHARE:

Advertiser PerceptionsMore than a quarter of programmatic decisions are made by agencies for their advertisers – up from 20% since September.

The revelation was presented by Mark Mahaney, managing director at RBC Capital Markets, at AdExchanger’s PROGRAMMATIC I.O conference in San Francisco on Thursday. The figures, which surprised Mahaney, show agencies make 27% of those decisions for their clients.

Yet there are still points of friction between agencies and marketers.

“The biggest issue is that, in general, the agency needs are not aligned with what the advertiser wants,” said Randy Cohen, president and COO of Advertiser Perceptions, who presented before a panel about advertisers’ insights on ad tech at PROGRAMMATIC I.O a day earlier. “There’s a disconnect around the different tech.”

Issues regarding transparency and arbitrage have eroded the trust between advertisers and their agencies. And with definitions of ad tech “murky at best, nonunderstandable at worst,” Cohen said, “advertisers are hearing ‘blah, blah, blah’” from their agencies when it comes to ad tech recommendations.

Unfortunately for those agencies, the marketing tech investments are controlled by marketers, said Randy Wootton, CEO of Rocket Fuel. If agencies aren’t trusted or if their tech recommendations don’t make sense, this could open the door for consultancies, like PwC and Deloitte Digital, to snap up business that traditionally went to agencies.

“Who will [marketers] trust to make those tech recommendations – an agency they’ve turned to for strategy and creative, or ad SI consultancy who can teach them [about technology]?” Wootton said.

Agencies argue they are making strides in shifting their traditional models to service clients’ needs around ad tech – which was why Publicis Groupe claimed it decentralized its VivaKi trading desk.

“The concept of the centralized trading desk had become outdated, and it didn’t really provide the level of service for clients we wanted it to,” said Justin Moreno, VP of solutions consulting at Publicis Media. “We had to bring the subject matter expertise of people who have their hands on the levers closer to the strategy team.”

Agencies are on the right path toward evolving their models to suit their clients, said Jonathan Hsia, managing partner and head of digital investment at Mindshare NA.

Subscribe

AdExchanger Daily

Get our editors’ roundup delivered to your inbox every weekday.

“There’s a perception that we push everything toward our trading desks and that’s not necessarily true,” he said. “CMOs will wake up one day and say, ‘I’m buying 40% of my media from tech vendors – why? We should be buying tech from vendors and media from agencies.’”

Tech giants like Google, Facebook and Yahoo often interface with clients directly when it comes to their tech. Yannis Dosios, VP of platform and exchange at Yahoo, said his company trains marketers, agencies and trading desks on how to use its platforms. But the vendor’s objective is to make a sale – which isn’t always in the best interest of the marketer.

According to Cohen, while advertisers may not be sure where to get their programmatic guidance, they’re positive about what they need: less tech jargon, more tangible business outcomes.

“The real issue is [being unable to measure] the benefit derived from utilizing technology and the ability to deliver on business goals,” he said.

The company that can provide that to clients – whether it be an agency, a consultancy or a vendor – will likely be its trusted guide.

Must Read

Comic: Gamechanger (Google lost the DOJ's search antitrust case)

DOJ v. Google: How Judge Brinkema Seems To Be Thinking After Week One

Where the DOJ v. Google ad tech antitrust trial stands after one week’s worth of remedies arguments.

Swish, A Company That's Bringing Programmatic to Product Sampling, Announces Seed Funding

Swish, a startup that partners with retailers to provide product full-size CPG samples to people doing their grocery shopping online, announces $2.3 million in seed funding.

DOJ v. Google: During Opening Arguments, The DOJ And Google Battle Over An AdX Divestiture

Court is back in session. And the fate of  the open internet is in the balance.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters
Chris Mufarrige, director, Bureau of Consumer Protection, FTC

FTC Consumer Protection Chief: No Easy Answers On Privacy, ‘Only Trade-Offs’

Privacy isn’t black-and-white, says the FTC’s Chris Mufarrige, promising evidence-driven consumer protection cases under the Trump administration.

How Encryption Keys Could Resolve The TID Furor

Rather than sharing universal TIDs that any DSP or curator can access, Raptive says publishers should instead share encrypted TIDs with an encryption key provided only to trusted demand-side partners.

Clear Channel Brings Mid-Flight Measurement To Its OOH Network

Clear Channel will provide advertisers weekly, mid-flight reports on outcomes driven by its inventory in order to bring OOH measurement closer to the speed of digital.