Home Online Advertising On Middlemen: Angel Investor Jerry Neumann Discusses The Online Advertising Value Chain

On Middlemen: Angel Investor Jerry Neumann Discusses The Online Advertising Value Chain

SHARE:

Middlemen ReactionAdExchanger.com recently asked several members of the advertising ecosystem about “Middlemen” and, specifically:

  • “Are there too many parties trying to insert themselves into the online advertising value chain? How do you see this playing out?”

The following contribution is from Jerry Neumann, an angel investor in The Trade Desk, 33Across, Domdex, CPM Advisors and Flurry and a co-founder of Root Markets, a quantitative marketing pioneer.

Once there was only one intermediary: the black box, the ad networks, AdSense.  They operated on a model that I’m personally familar with from raising children: you get what you get and you don’t get upset. Then the producers and users of ad inventory decided to grow up and take control of their own process -deconstruct the black boxes and start to learn themselves what works and why.

A network of intermediaries sprang up -densely interconnected but none irreplaceable (but still each their own little black box.).  With this network, marketers and publishers can access and control data and learn by monitoring the seams between the various companies.  They can also swap out any given intermediary for another if they think they will get better results.  This evolutionary process, while painful, is leading us to not just better advertising, but better marketing.  And the more atomic the process–the more intermediaries there are–the better our ability to experiment and discover.

But, then the issue becomes not how many intermediaries there are, but how much of the spend they are consuming.  Several commentators, Jonathan Mendez particularly well, have noted that publishers get only about 20% of the marketer spend.  For marketers, a better way to say this is that up to 80% of their interactive budget is spent on transaction fees.  This is way too high: it should be less than 40%. In this sense, there are too many intermediaries, each intent on taking a large enough chunk out of the media spend that they might someday be worth what they promised their investors.  The marketers are torn between wanting more granularity and wanting less transactional overhead.

The publishers think they want fewer intermediaries, but absent higher demand for inventory, having fewer intermediaries will not raise publisher CPMs.  The opposite is true. If you don’t believe me, plug AdSense back in and see what the single intermediary–Google–nets you.  Publishers right now are price takers.  There are two ways they can increase CPMs: make the marketers dumber by forcing them to forgo the quantitative marketing tools they have adopted, or make themselves smarter by adopting some quantitative marketing tools themselves.  The smart ones are working on the latter.  This means more intermediaries, not fewer.

In the next few years, the tension between having many intermediaries–allowing control of and learning from the process–and having few intermediaries-reducing transaction costs–will be resolved by there being three direct intermediaries at most: buyer’s agent, seller’s agent and marketplace (supported by various technology and data providers, who will not themselves be intermediaries.)  To get there, each intermediary must become completely transparent to its clients.  No more black boxes.  Buyer’s agents and seller’s agents must move away from being arbitrageurs and return to the traditional professional services function of trusted adviser.

More opinions on Middlemen>>>

Must Read

WPP’s Angela Steele On AI, CTV And The ‘Trusted Growth Partner’ Pitch

AI is taking over the media and tech industries in the name of simplification, and marketers are pining for provable campaign outcomes, including from TV. These shifts are also causing significant change in Agency Holdco Land, according to Angela Steele, the first chief client officer for WPP Media US.

Shopify Noses Further Into Ad Tech With Campaign Autopilot Expansion

No major retail media player has taken as circumspect an approach to ad revenue as Shopify. But the company has recently taken its next important step with a product called Campaign Autopilot.

Benji Shomair, VP of monetization, OpenAI & Terry Kawaja, CEO, LUMA Partners (photo credit: Jenna Bascom Photography / LUMA Partners)

In OpenAI’s Ad Business, Advertisers Come Third

OpenAI’s head of monetization, Benji Shomair makes the case for ads as a way to bring ChatGPT to more people, with user trust taking priority over advertiser demands.

Privacy! Commerce! Connected TV! Read all about it. Subscribe to AdExchanger Newsletters

The Trade Desk’s Revenue Slipped In Q3. If It Wants To Grow, It Must Evolve

In Q3, The Trade Desk beat the admittedly pessimistic revenue forecast it set for itself earlier this year. But growth has stalled.

Human artist painting on canvas, while beside him an AI robot stands copying the artwork onto its own canvas. Depict the controversy surrounding Generative AI and the creativity of human artists

Viant Buys Waymark For $20 Million, Because CTV Needs More Ads (More!)

Viant is doubling down on CTV with its $20 million Waymark acquisition, betting that AI-generated ads can bring more advertisers to streaming TV.

Smart AI Chatbot Virtual Assistant Vector Icon design

TIME’s AI Agents Do The Coordinating, And Its Sellers Still Do The Selling

TIME is using AI agents to draft proposals and troubleshoot campaigns – but not to replace the human relationships that drive ad sales.